Monday, November 30, 2009

Where the Sacred Serpent Rests, a Mine Intrudes-RESPONSE

I specifically chose this article as a medium between current and past events. I wanted to give background information so that my audience could create a connection between what used to be and what is. The problems that I have been talking (e.g. destruction of societies and culture by corporate mines) have caused resistance and disruption for many years. This isn’t a crisis that has suddenly erupted, but one that has been boiling for longer than most of our lives. I always recognized that this wasn’t a recent dilemma but this article gave me a stronger perspective on the time period I must include in my research. This next statement may come across as ignorant seeing as I have been studying this topic for a couple of months. It wasn’t until this article that I realized the true significance of what is taking place, and the validity of the articles I have incorporated into my blog. I suppose I was assuming that this destruction would never affect me and that it was only happening in some other world. The realization that all this destruction has been going on even before I was born and in my own safety zone has forced me to snap into attention and consider the events that are happening as real life happenings.
Other than what I have previously mentioned there was another change in my general view of this topic. As I have continued my blog my undeniable disgust of many countries’ governments and the CEO’s of the mining companies has expanded. This article did portray an aspect of these international tyrants that I must have overlooked. There were actually some acts of kindness towards the aboriginal groups! Wow! Maybe it was just the reporter masking the companies attempt at winning over the community, but I’m going to be optimistic and believe that there was actually an act of gratitude between the two opposing groups. Maybe my bird’s eye opinion of all these situations has been clouded by biased reporters and my choice to see only what I wanted to see. I should have researched further into what these companies have been doing to benefit these minorities, instead of assuming that they have done nothing.
There are some new questions that I am considering. My research only goes as far back as 1998, but how far back does this problem really go? When were the first mines actually created? When did they boom, and develop into international companies? How far back can I research until I can no longer find articles regarding the entwinement of culture and mining? In all of my history textbooks there have been pictures of settlers mining for gold or coal in the Midwest. My most recent introduction was to the Roman conquest, and their connection to mining in Africa and the Middle East. This new direction regarding my topic will require large amounts of background research and study. I will have to study the history of mining and the countries that have become influential in the industry. Over this entire article was very helpful and allowed many ideas to be created. It has opened new paths which I hope to continue following.

Where the Sacred Serpent Rests, a Mine Intrudes-NOTES

  • Gundjehmi Aboriginal Corporation- “seeks to protect local Aborigines and their land
  • Jabiru is a mining/tourist town
    • Population of 1,000
      • Aborigines equal 10% of town population, and ¼ of the immediate area population
    • Located in the Kakadu National Park
      • Thousands of crocodiles, 280 species of birds, rich cultural center for the Aborigines (20,000 year old Aboriginal art rock drawings).
      • 300,000+ tourists visit each year.
      • In 1992 the area was inscribed as a Word Heritage site as defined by Unesco
  • A giant open pit Uranium mine is located 10 miles away from the town and park.
  • Uranium buyers include France, Germany, United States, and Japan
    • The Ranger mine distributes royalties to the Aboriginals for their land.
      • Royalties increase over the years
  • Close to the pit is the home of Dadbe, the Rainbow Serpent, a mythical ancestor of the Aboriginal people
  • Energy Resources of Australia Ltd. Of Sydney is planning on tapping another uranium site 15 miles away.
    • The new mines plans on granting huge benefits to the Aborigines.
  • The Aboriginal people do not want the money, but would rather close all mining plants and re-establish their ancient society.
    • ''The money is going to kill us. Everybody already forgets about our culture. The new generation -- all they want is cars and a trip to the pub.''
  • Federal court papers plants to delay if not block and export permit for Jabiluka uranium.
    • A petition to Unesco asks for Kakadu to be placed on the World Heritage Property in Danger list.
  • The mine’s waste rock dump is contaminating the Aborigines water flow, especially during the wet season.
    • The company states that the water is “lightly contaminated” and represents “no danger”
  • The Aboriginal Project Committee was set up by the Australian Government to examine the effect of uranium development on indigenous people.
  • Energy Resources placed a seismic recorder near Mount Brockman to insure that blasts are below any level that might bother the Rainbow Serpent.
    • They have donated $130 million to the indigenous people.
      • Some of the money was invested into a three hotels which are partly owned by Aboriginal clans, and run by an American Management Company, Southern Pacific Hotels

Friday, November 20, 2009

Response to Global Effects of Mining

Great Job! The notes form your blog are fantastic and slightly overwhelming. You clearly put a great deal of time and thought into each post. One of the the most noticeable and successful aspects of each post is how well the facts in your notes are separated from the reflection. One thing to keep in mind: the notes are very well written, but be careful not to to weight the reader down with so much information that the core ideas and messages of the post is lost in less important statistics.
As I said above, there is a clear and effective distinction between the facts and your thoughts. I noticed many common themes running through successive posts—the idea of corporation vs. community is very strong, as well as your discussion of various human rights violations and crimes. The best way to evoke emotion from the reader is to leave your response open-ended (which you do for the most part), maybe in a question form so the readers can ask themselves "Huh, why haven't I heard about this huge problem before?" and the like.
Each of the posts vary just enough to keep the reader engages but also interconnect to carry an overall theme. While each topic changes the area or the main problem, everything relates to each other. A good use of this month's background post would be to use one text to thoroughly explain the history of corporate mining and why the situation is as bad as it is now. You have given parts of the description in each post, but a unified base of the topic would be far stronger for the reader and save unnecessary background work later on. Keep an eye on reliable news sources (reuters, NYT, etc.), and double check the websites validity before using it.
The blog itself is complete. well laid-out, and the citation is all correct. The link for The Historic Bolivian Mine UPI story seems to be expired; just double check that. Keep up the great work.

Thursday, November 19, 2009

Second Peer Blog Response

From what I read about this topic in the posts, I've found it pretty interesting. The notes are extremely thorough and detailed and very informative. After reading the responses to the notes, I've learned a lot about this topic and have developed my own opinion on it. All of the posts are titled correctly and the colors are easy to read. All five of the posts are complete. Visually the posts are a little boring, maybe add some picture of some of the mines that people are working in.

Response to Global Mining Blog

The notes for this blog are intensely detailed, and anything but brief. The responses are well organized persuasive for the most part, especially the response to the article about the Bolivian mine. The author of this blog obviously has a topic that is always developing, and will have no shortage of material to cover. The blog could be more reader friendly, wiht some of the responses single spaced, but other than that, I did not see many more problems.

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

A Fatally Attractive Mining Business-RESPONSE

This article helped me define the meaning of corporate destruction of a community as well as self-destruction by a community. Corporate destruction is the annihilation of a community through the actions of greedy companies and international money bags. Self-destruction of a community is the demolition of a community caused by the greed of local citizens and the inability for local groups to work together in defeating the intruders. Of all the articles that I have reviewed and used in my I-Search, this is the first that did not include the names of big companies, and that focuses only on the local action. Once again I have seen the issue from another perspective, and it’s just as frightening. The article was mainly focused on the violence that has occurred between gangs and the owners of local mineral sources. The two events that really struck me the most was the rape and strangling of a 6 year old boy, and the rape of a mentally handicapped woman. These were both done because of superstitions that by completing these disgusting events they would find bigger and more pure gemstones. What amount of greed could drive somebody to kill an innocent child just to have the chance of becoming rich?

There was no remarkable change in my thinking after reading the article, but it inspired me to further research gangs and their connection to mining. Since Maine has not produced many hardcore gangsters, it’s always interesting to learn about the “dark side”. (George Lucas, Star Wars) A question that did form in my mind is how am I going to connect all of these different negative parts of mining into one topic? As I stated in the previous response to the Peruvian drug dealers, I have a total of 7(now 8) different perspectives. That’s 8 different topics that have stimulated my eager mind, and that number will continually grow as the months go by! If I am going to include gangs or drug trades in my I-Search, I’m going to have to research more about the gangs themselves, and their backgrounds. Many gangs have corrupted their government’s system, allowing illegal manufacturing or licensing to be possible. I would need to research about the governments in the countries that I end up focusing on.

A Fatally Attractive Mining Business-NOTES

  • Mineral wealth in the larger Taita-Taveta District, Mombasa, Kenya has caused much more trouble and destruction than wealth and happiness.
    • Gangs of illegal miners are terrorizing towns because of local discoveries of precious gems.
    • Zururas are the local name for the gangs.
  • A local man found a gem which later led him to a source of gemstones worth millions of shillings.
    • Zururas raided his 30 acre farm and started mining his land with out his permission.
    • They shot his daughter, seriously injured his wife, and destroyed his property.
  • There has been no government action towards persecuting many of the illegal miners.
    • Politicians have actually been causing tension and influencing the youth to fight people over control of mineral sources.
  • Not only are the owners of the sources being terrorized, but the gemstone dealers as well.
    • International gemstone dealer Campbell Bridges was speared to death a couple of hours after reporting to the police death threats that were sent to him. Four of his managers and his son were seriously injured.
    • In this past three months, three gemstone dealers have been killed and 10 others seriously injured.
  • Groups or gangs are clashing over ownership of mines, causing scores of people to be injured.
    • Last month armed robbers killed a man and seriously wounded a couple. They stole more than 2 million shillings from the couple who happened to be gemstone dealers in the area. The brawl was caused by ownership controversies.
  • In a time span of about one year, the community that was once known for its very low crime rate has witness a series of armed robberies, violent fights, and deaths all related to the mine.
    • The thieves dress as prospective buyers and steal from the legitimate miners.
  • Many of the illegal miners have superstitions that have also affected the community.
    • A six year old boy was “sodomised” (raped) and strangled to death in what police feel was a ritual murder.
    • The miners rape mentally handicapped women because they feel it brings them luck when mining.
  • Taita-Taveta Small-scale Miners Cooperative Society stated the region is losing investors because illegal mining by gangs isn’t stopping.
    • The investors are the foundation of the local economy and the country can’t afford to lose such opportunities.
    • Kenya has been dealing with economic ruin for many decades now.
  • Large scale miners complain highly about the lack of enough police stations.
    • The police cannot fight the crime because of distance and logistical problems.
    • The police say that the large-scale miners are causing tension because they are not seeking consent from landowners after they have been licensed by the Commissioner of Mines and Geology.
    • The Education board blames Geological Department officials for fuelling the controversy because they are taking sides.
  • The only step towards fixing the problems has been to suggest real miners wear arm bands.

Thursday, November 5, 2009

Peru Mine Killings Work of Drug Trade: Businessmen- RESPONSE

After reading the article I felt it was very helpful to learn about not only the arguments between mining companies and the public, but also about the tension between citizens of an area and gangs or drug groups also in that area. I never realized that communities can be pitted against each other. The mining companies must get away with a lot, because if the people are arguing amongst themselves they won’t be as keen to notice the mines developing or making large scale decisions behind their backs. By reading this article, I have once again discovered another point of view. So far, my spectrum of perspectives includes the mining companies, the communities surrounding the mines, outside organizations, the government, subgroups within communities, and random individuals who have responded to the articles with their opinions. In total that makes 7 different views (including my own) on one broad topic. This contribution does change my thinking, allowing a deeper view into the effects on relationships in society. Large mining corporations can destroy relationships, but also have the capacity to build stronger bonds. As mentioned in the previous articles that I have researched, many of the groups have become one strong pack. They have learned that together they can achieve more, and become more effective. At the same time, in a different location, and maybe a different type of mine, the previously accepted kinship deteriorated, splitting those protesting and those supporting mine activities. As shown in this article there are even clashes between two groups that are protesting together, but one wants to be more discreet about their disagreement while the other wants the whole world to notice.
In all my other responses, I’ve questioned the sanity of the mine leaders and associates. How could they be so inconsiderate and selfish? That question still, and will always remain, but the question that sprouted after reading this article concerns the drug traders. I poise the same question to them: how can you be so inconsiderate and selfish? Whether or not the local people have welcomed them, these illegal farms are still located on the fertile soil close to these previously or still tightly knit communities. By burning and attacking the mines they are inevitably burning and attacking the innocent people that work there. By trying to be discreet, they are actually bringing more attention to themselves. If the mines wanted to, they could destroy the entire society if that were to prevent the destruction of their buildings and equipment. How can these dealers not realize that they are getting nowhere by force, and that they mean nothing to these corporations? They are hurting the people and not the companies. The mines could probably care less if the people died, so the message they want to get across, by killing and torturing, is not getting very far (at least for me).
Governments play a huge role in the growth and development of a mine. They are the ones that allow or turn down the ability to begin excavating rock. As I slowly begin to pinpoint exactly what my I-Search is going to be on, I will probably choose one country that is being severely affected economically and socially. After choosing this location, I should then research what the government has done, or in some cases hasn’t done, on the topic of mining. Whether they have promoted it, or decided to turn it down, it will add yet another perspective to my list (that would make 8!). If the governments have supported the mining, it will be really interesting to learn their reasons. What I must make sure that I do not do, is ignore or disregard the opinions of those that disagree with me. That would weaken my research, and make it into more of a persuasive report and not an informative presentation.

Peru Mine Killings Work of Drug Trade: Businessmen- NOTES

  • The Rio Blanco copper project has caused much disruption in the surrounding community.
    • The site is located in northern Peru.
    • It is owned by China’s Zijin Mining Group, which bought it from Monterrico Metals of Britain.
    • The mine has a net profit of 1.4 billion dollars.
  • A weekend attack on the mine left three dead.
    • Large fields of Opium poppies are cultivated and grown for heroin trade in the mountainous area.
      • The attack is suspected to be caused by drug traffickers who want to keep the area underdeveloped to protect their trade.
    • The mine was invaded by 15 to 20 gunmen who fired at employees and then set the complex on fire.
  • There have been previous attacks on the same site, and police believe that this is a revenge attack stemmed from the constant controversy.
  • It has become a trend for big mines to bring up big problems and become tangled with all ready established trades.
    • Regarding the confrontation between drug traffickers and mining, the attacks are usually caused because “Narcos” do not like commercial companies to bring any attention to an area that they are all ready using for illegal trade.
  • Peru is the world’s No. 2 cocaine producer.
    • The government has leased concessions to foreign mining companies, giving them rights to look for minerals near the cocaine farms.
  • According to the company and those associated with it, the townspeople are in support of the development and construction of the mine.
    • This statement seems to be disproved by past uprising such as the death and torture of 3 protestors in 2005. Many of the community members surrounding the mines were against the development because they said it would cause pollution and hurt their water supplies.
  • President Garcia has put much effort into brining in foreign investors to Peru, but the locals are critical because he seems to be ignoring the environmental and cultural concerns of the big mines.
    • The government has yet to win the debate over the benefits of big mines being introduced in isolated towns in the Andes.
    • Citizens in poverty stricken towns are on the forefront of the argument with foreign firms and the government over mining and oil projects in Peru.
    • In June three dozen people died in Peru’s northern jungle, as police broke up roadblocks set by indigenous groups opposed to oil exploration in there ancestral lands.