Friday, March 19, 2010

Summative Response

It began with a comment about a newly purchased wedding ring. It has flourished into an infatuation with blood diamonds and their gloomy past. I’ve never liked the look of diamonds. They’ve always been too glitzy and shimmery for my simple taste. When people used to ask me why I didn’t like them, the answer was simply a shrug. My shrug is now a passionate remark regarding the unhealthy past of these minerals. Just thinking about the possible deaths and mutilations that are part of a diamond’s story is enough to make me feel disgusted. This reaction has brought me here, to the end of my almost 6 month research journey. The first version of my thesis went something like this: Mining is affecting societies around the world. This has been severely edited and modified to: The greed for blood minerals is eroding African societies.

It wasn’t until my interview that I finally realized how much I had learned. I was nervous about talking to Mr. Steele-Maley because his knowledge of the subject was intimidating. When I sat down in his room and we started debating and discussing, my nerves cleared right up. I was able to answer some of his questions as well as comment on his replies. I would ask him a question and five minutes later we were still talking about it! I had researched enough to know what questions needed to be asked to further deepen my understanding. I guess you could call it a “Eureka!” moment. I had gone from not even knowing what blood minerals were, to being able to hold a conversation with someone who had been studying African mining for most of his adult career.

At the beginning of my research, I chose my articles based on length. If they were long, it meant my notes would be long. I had forgotten my own rule. Cut to the bone and do NOT drone. As time progressed, I have been selecting my articles based on pertinence and quality. If the source is vague and the writing is poor, then the article is “voted off the island”. The articles that have proven to be most fruitful originate from African and European newspapers. I wasn’t actually very surprised to see that the American media hadn’t covered the topic recently because it’s “passé”. The African sources were a little biased, but it was quite helpful to see the opinion of the locals. On the contrary, the European papers were simple and honest. It wasn’t until I watched “Blood Diamonds”, a movie starring Leonardo DiCaprio about the diamond war in Sierra Leone, that I decided to focus only on Africa. Even though it was a Hollywood movie and everybody knows that typically their movies aren’t historically accurate, this was incredible. It showed the mutilations and the pain. The brutality wasn’t softened or romanticized. This movie may have been my largest break through.

Each article read blamed a different group for the violence. African papers were spilt between supporting the rebels, the “government” or the investors, while the international reporters always bashed the locals. In this way, the articles were connected. Each was pointing a finger at a different person or institution. It wasn’t until I started thinking about this essay that the links even dawned on me. I read through my responses and they are incredibly similar. My passion may have increased by ten, but the subjects are all close. The metals involved are similar, the people affected are always the same, and the causes of the violence are usually related. This is not simply a coincidence. One of the main connecting ideas is that everything is based on the consumer. Through the consumer, the war is planted and grown. With no investors, there is no demand, and without demand, violence is unnecessary. As my thesis became more focused, I wanted to look further into the diamond market. Through the help of Mr. Steele-Maley, I’ve made a lot of progress and learned much about demand and supply.

The experience of researching such a complicated topic has been incredible. I’ve learned a lot about how to conduct research as well as the difference between a report and a research paper. Most of all, I’ve been introduced to a topic that has captured my mind. Blood diamonds have so many interesting aspects and bends in their historical and political road. My progression from knowing nothing about this topic, to knowing so much has taught me a lot about the specific subject as well as about the pace of knowledge acquisition and its cumulative effect. It has resulted in an experience that goes beyond this English project and into a socio-political and every day experience that I may address within the MUN scenario as well as within a jewelry shop, if I ever go into one.

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Response to Interview (18)

My interview was incredibly helpful! I wasn’t expecting a lot of new information because I thought (proven completely wrong) that I knew everything about mining in Africa. The all the new ideas and information was overwhelming! It helped to be knowledgeable about the topic, but it was so interesting to get another persons perspective. Some of the questions that I asked Mr. Steele- Maley were very hard to answer because they have been unanswered questions for years. For the life of me I couldn’t think of a response or action that hadn’t been done yet. Somehow Mr. S answered the question and also gave the history behind his opinion. This guy is smart! None of my articles focus on the history of Africa as a nation so it was very interesting to learn about colonization and how it destroyed the historic culture of Africa previously well preserved. So the bad relationship between the west and Africa isn’t one that was produced because of the diamonds, but a connection that began with the first white settlers.

I am very passionate about blood minerals and Africa, and it was so cool to be personally talking to someone just as adamant. Our interview went longer than expected because I would ask sub-questions and then we would go off on tangents and after 5 minutes of discussing Africa I would realize that there were 10 more questions to go! He gave me ideas about educating the public, and how the fate of African people affected by blood minerals lies in the hands of the consumers. My previous opinion was that the investors were the ones that had the most control, but without consumers investors would go bankrupt. It’s in our hands. Most blame the people above them (like me) but in truth all the weight is falling on our shoulders. We, the civilians of an ever turning world, have the fate of a society’s life in our hands. The responsibility is overwhelming and that’s why we tend to hand the torch off to someone else. The National Breast Cancer Foundation’s slogan is pertinent to the situation in Africa: “Hope starts with us.”

The resources that were suggested have proven to be very helpful. Mr. Steele-Maley gave be a colonization book, and article on the Congo, and many websites. It’s getting more and more challenging finding an article that doesn’t mirror previously used articles. With new subjects to follow, and resources to explore, this interview has been the most helpful part of the blog experience so far. I learned a lot about writing questions and how to make them non-personal. Mr. S provided fruitful information and answered some very complicated questions in a way that I, and other students, can understand. I thank him very much for his time and the thoughts he has planted in my head.

Sunday, March 7, 2010

Completed Interview Q and A (17)

1.) Why is Africa the main area of conflict, ignoring the reason of large mining sources?

This all began because of the legacy of colonialism/ neocolonialism. During the time of colonialism (1885-1960) an industry of gem mining was created and controlled by colonial powers while they inhabited Africa. Soon the majority of these foreigners had left the continent, and with them they took the organization of the gem industry. All that was left was an incredibly dysfunctional monopoly whose roots became corrupt which in turn created a black market of small scale gem production. DeBeers is an excellent example of a small black market going international. The base of the problem began in colonization and the continual struggle of international versus national control of diamond rich areas.


2.) How can international aid help without destroying national sovereignty?

That's the ultimate question. The African Union will play the largest role as a mediator and assistant between international aid and local culture. Countries troubled with blood diamonds must support the AU because they are the most local and reliable help. The west disrupted the balance of Africa’s cultures in the 1885 BerlinAfrica into designated “countries” or areas. Strengthening indigenous institutions with favorable world trade organization policy changes will allow culture to be protected. I think we have the ability to forgive World Bank debt and IMF debt to Africa. By so, a leveled playing field for development in all countries will be possible. The debt of the Congo is still being paid back from when a dictator stole from the resource rich country. A question towards the AU is this: Should the country of Congo have to pay back its debts? It’s the lack of funds that is holding them back from developing and moving forward. conference. This convention resulted in the splitting up of


3.) What can international mineral investors (corporate) do so as to decrease the amount of mineral based deaths?
Investors must trace the source of their sold minerals. After the Kimberly Process was initiated, DeBeers has been able to track almost all of their sources. The ideal situation is this: A company who is selling fair trade who is competing against a company saying it's "mostly fair trade" will, in the end, earn more profits. Sourcing is the first step for companies towards solving all the mineral based wars. Instead of having a middle man take the diamonds from the mines to the investors, companies should send their men directly into the areas. This will hopefully solve the problem of smelting the minerals before selling them so that the illegal stones get melted into legal ones and are sold as “legal”.


4.) What political reforms could be made to the current system in African countries to diminish the blood mineral violence?
Blood minerals are a huge political and ethnic issue as well as a major humanitarian crisis. In Eastern Congo there is a decade long legacy of war that was originally started in Rwanda and that has spilled over into the lakes region since the Rwandan genocide. There is so much wrong, that political reforms won’t aid because there is no government. There may be no political reforms able to cause significant change but the economy is a large structure in need of rebuilding. To create a framework for peace and stability there would have to be an economy. Development drives internal economy so by allowing greater companies to create jobs the rebels would hopefully drop their weapons and work.


5.) What solutions will keep the mass refugee problem from further imposing on neighboring countries?
Groups such as the UN must address the ethnic conflict as well as the diamond conflict. The IDP camps built in Northern Uganda are effective but not ideal. The government set up secure cities with walls surrounding the entire area, much like Darfur and its massive IDP camps. The Darfur IDP camps waited out the war that they had to wage with the lords resistance army. The lakes region is a hornet’s nest buzzing with so many different conflicts that 800,000 people were killed within a 6 week span (Rwanda). This refugee problem is deep and can't be solved by a quick fix United Nations resolution. It will take much time, and I feel there are no quick actions that haven’t already been initiated.


6.) What are some short term (1-5 years) solutions to help stabilize the government?
Support of the AU, the release of IMF debts and WB debts, a complete reorientation of world trade structure, and creating whole economies are all short term solutions. Whole economies are when the growing, selling, and manufacturing are local. African nations must have a local primary (raw material), secondary (processing), tertiary (industry supporting the secondary; workers, hospitals, stores) and quaternary (internet based) industries. Africa has a primary resource industry and they NEED the secondary realm to gain any kind of foot hold into the economy. They need to consume what they produce and produce what they consume.

7.) What are some long term solutions (10-15 years) to help stabilize the government?
The possible redistribution of borders in Africa. The most exciting idea would be a pan-African country or the redrawing of the borders from what was imposed by the Europeans, to ethnic borders.

8. Would nationalizing mineral companies or only allowing local companies to mine help the economy?

By taking the trade out of the black market it will help build facilities e.g. fair trade movement with coffee in Columbia. The government and the world must listen to the plight of the people. We must work from a human rights framework to legitimize the people.

9.) What are some resources that would provide further information regarding conflict minerals in Africa?
-AU website- http://www.africa-union.org/
-UN missions to the AU
-Understanding the development theory
-Emory International studies site- http://www.icis.emory.edu/
-Human geography: Landscape of Human Activities (pg 82)
-Globalization 101


10.) Would the education of consumers prove fruitful in the attempts to stop the purchase of blood minerals?
YES! That means that this 1980's-2010 addiction to consumerism will finally be educated. Consumers don't care about the history behind their purchases. They may be paying financially for the product but they are not paying the emotional price, the price of pain, death, and misery. You’re essentially wearing labor and death around your neck or finger. It’s unbelievable how much people are exploited for one engagement ring. If diamonds were regulated in their origin and you had to pay for what they were really worth then you would get a smaller but more humanitarian focused industry.

11.) What sanctions can international organizations (such as United Nations) impose to control the flow of blood minerals?
Development issue can be addressed by the World Trade Organization. They could put stiffer regulatory measures on all international companies doing business in Africa. All organizations, not just the UN, must demand higher standards. There must be a larger will and presence to enforce tracking measures. The UN could assist in replacing corporate greed for humanitarianism. If the UN tried putting strict regulations on African countries it would be like taking a starving poor person and putting a fence around them. The UN must collaborate with governments and companies to not force the peoples of Africa into a dog house.

Interview Questions for Thomas Steele-Maley (17)

1.) Why is Africa the main area of conflict, ignoring the reason of large mining sources?


2.) How can international aid help without destroying national sovereignty?


3.) What can international mineral investors (corporate) do so as to decrease the amount of mineral based deaths?


4.) What political reforms could be made to the current system in African countries to diminish the blood mineral violence?


5.) What solutions will keep the mass refugee problem from further imposing on neighboring countries?


6.) What are some short term (1-5 years) solutions to help stabilize the government?


7.) What are some long term solutions (10-15 years) to help stabilize the government?


8. Would nationalizing mineral companies or only allowing local companies to mine help the economy?


9.) What are some resources that would provide further information regarding conflict minerals in Africa?


10.) Would the education of consumers prove fruitful in the attempts to stop the purchase of blood minerals?


11.) What sanctions can international organizations (such as United Nations) impose to control the flow of blood minerals?