Friday, December 4, 2009

Black Mesa-RESPONSE

“Roberta Blackgoat described to me a paradigm in which the earth is a sacred and living organism, in which human beings and the earth exist in a reciprocal relationship. This reciprocity is the foundation for her life. We are the people of the earth’s surface, she told me, and no more important than the winged creatures or four-legged beings. ‘The coal is the liver of the earth,’ she said. ‘When you take it out, she dies.’” These Indians were relocated by the U.S. government, and now the land they were forced on is being destroyed. Where are they to go? By forcing somebody out of their home and relocating them, one assumes that their next home will be theirs for good. I guess our nation doesn’t agree with me. I hadn’t actually heard of this problem until a friend of mine from Arizona came back and explained it to me. She attends Prescott College, about 2 hours from Black Mesa, and is very active in the protesting of the mine, and the helping of the people. She mentioned that the Hopi Tribe and the Navajo nation are actually historical enemies. They were forced together by the relocation causing much angst, but have one thing in common: their distaste of the Peabody Mine. The mine has destroyed their only water supply, and scraped away their sacred mountains. The Navajo Generating Station’s name is rich in irony, since fewer than half of Navajo families have electricity. The U.S. government was the single largest owner. The Department of the Interior needed the electricity to run a federal water project, the Central Arizona Project, locally known as CAP. CAP is a concrete highway for water–infrastructure that lifts the waters of the Colorado River over three mountain ranges in order to carry it to Phoenix and Tucson. “With enough money, anything is possible,” a government engineer stated. With no water, and living in the middle of a desert, these Indians are losing what little was given to them. They have learned to deal with their forced settings, and now the mines are taking away even that. The huge slurry pipe drains and leaks onto the desert soil. Since the water is being taken from the aquifer the Indians can’t grow crops or any agriculture. It’s disgusting what our government has done to these natives. To the people that were here first. Isn’t it an American tradition: “First come first serve”? We treat them like they are of a lower class, and yet we say in our Declaration of Independence that “All men are created equal.” I just can’t seem to understand out countries logic.

I have been trying to focus solely on international mining problems and steering clear of anything within the U.S. For some reason I thought I knew everything about mining in the U.S., and I wanted to research information that would be new. When my friend began discussing the Black Mesa situation, she was so passionate about it, that I was caught up in her flurry of information. I think it would be really interesting to continue researching this area. I would need a lot of background information, especially to explain the relocation history of the Indians, and the mining technique that Peabody is using. This could tie into a larger research about the effect mining has had on American Indians. There must be other areas that are being affected, and it would connect with the Black Mesa area. Our government took away all of the Native American’s land away, and now we are destroying it again. We placed them in a barren land with no promises but that this was the Indians new home.


Black Mesa-NOTES

· Black Mesa, AZ, is the indigenous home of Dine (Navajo) and Hopi peoples.
o It is also home to the largest coal deposit in the United States.
· Peabody Western Coal Company produces 21 billion tons of coal in that area.
o Long-term value for the company is as high as $100 billion.
o Strip mining operations on Black Mesa began in 1968.
o Until recently the location was North America’s largest strip mining operation.
o Only site operation long-distance coal slurry pipeline.
§ The 273 mile long pipe used to feed the Mojave Generating Station, a power plant in Laughlin, Nevada.
· Loss of groundwater in Black Mesa has severely affected the tribes.
o Peabody has taken over a billion gallons of water from the local aquifer each year to liquefy their coal slurry.
o The aquifer is the Indians only source of water on the entire reservoir.
· The Kayenta Mine, which supplies the Navajo Generating Station, is also located in Black Mesa.
o The coal power generated from the two plants has supplied energy for Las Vegas, Los Angeles, and Phoenix for three decades.
o Royalties and taxes provide 80 percent of the Hopi general operating budget and 60 percent of the Navajo general fund budget.
· The Mohave Generating Station was annihilated.
o Reason 1: Clean Air Act lawsuit was inducted.
o Reason 2: Navajo and Hopi tribes passed resolutions ceasing Peabody’s use of the Black Mesa aquifer.
§ The coal plant was the dirtiest in the Western U.S., emitting up to 40,000 tons of sulfur dioxide per year.
· 14,000 indigenous people, mostly Navajo, have been removed from their lands since the created of the reserve.
o The largest removal of Native Americans since the 1880s.
§ John McCain authored the relocation bill (Navajo-Hopi Settlement Act).
· The suspension of the Black Mesa mine and slurry line had a negative economic impact for the Hopi Tribe and Navajo nations.
o Unemployment is close to 40 percent.
· The people of Black Mesa are being considered trespassers in their own homes under federal law.
· Peabody Coal Co. plans to seize another 19,000 acres of sacred land beyond the 67,000 acres already taken by the company.
· President Chester Arthur designated the land area to the Indians "so that white Mormon families would not settle there."
o By giving the land to the Indians, the government gained the title to whatever mineral resources lay beneath the acres.
o If it had been given to the Mormons for $1.25 per acre, the settlers would control the minerals, and the government would not reap the financial benefits.
· Black Mesa, AZ, is the indigenous home of Dine(Navajo) and Hopi peoples
Also home to the largest coal deposit in the United States.
· Peabody Western Coal Company produces 21 billion tons of coal
o Long-term value for the company is as high as $100 billion.
o Strip mining operations on Black Mesa began in 1968.
o Until recently the location was North America’s largest strip mining operation
o Only site operation long-distance coal slurry pipeline.
§ The 273 mile long pipe used to feed the Mojave Generating Station, a power plant in Laughlin, Nevada.
· Loss of groundwater in Black Mesa has severely effected the tribes
o Peabody has taken over a billion gallons of water from the local aquifer each year to liquefy the coal slurry
o The aquifer is the Indians only source of water on the entire reservoir
· The Kayenta Mine, which supplies the Navajo Generating Station is also located on Black Mesa
o The coal power generated from the two plants supplies energy for Las Vegas, Los Angeles, and Phoenix for three decades.
o Royalties and taxes provide 80 percent of the Hopi general operating budget and 60 percent of the Navajo general fun budget.
· The Mohave Generating Station was annihilated
o Reason 1: Clean Air Act lawsuit was inducted
o Reason 2: Navajo and Hopi tribes passed resolutions ceasing Peabody’s use of the Black Mesa aquifer
§ The coal plant was the dirtiest in the Western U.S., emitting up to 40,000 tons of sulfur dioxide per year.
· 14,000 indigenous people, mostly Navajo, have been removed from their lands
o The largest removal of Native Americans since the 1880s.
§ John McCain authored the relocation bill (Navajo-Hopi Settlement Act)
· The suspension of the Black Mesa mine and slurry line had a negative economic impact for the Hopi Tribe and Navajo nations
o Unemployment is close to 40 percent
· The people of Black Mesa are being considered trespassers in their own homes under federal law.
· Peabody Coal Co. plans to seize another 19,000 acres of sacred land beyond the 67,000 acres already taken by the company
· President Chester Arthur designated the land area to the Indians so that white Mormon families would not settle there.
o By giving the land to the Indians, the government gained the title to whatever mineral resources lay beneath those acres.
o If it had been given to the Mormons for $1.25 per acre, the settlers would control the minerals, and the government would not reap the financial benefits.

A New Era for Bougainville-RESPONSE

This article was fascinating because I knew so much about the history of the war already. Even though Mr. Pip by Lloyd Jones was a fictional story, the setting was completely real and the murders and destruction of villages and lives was also true. The constant killings between the Australians (redskins) and the natives (Rambos) came alive in this public article. The writing and presentation of the article was rather dry and there was no opinion or passion behind the words. What it did provide was a background of a historical event that is still happening and pertains to my topic and also a class book. Each article that I research forces me to see that this problem is sadly real and it isn’t going away. The mass murders of 20,000 people over the exploitation of workers and the money laundering of a mine has caused international interference. The only reason why this mining company is facing legal court is because of their unpaid taxes. It sounds exactly like the case with Al Capone. He annihilated the lives of many but his incarceration was based off of unpaid taxes. The fact that I am able to make that comparison is terrifying. These people deserve to be treated correctly because the end product of many mines is destruction.

The island of Bougainville is very small. When a statement is announced that their environment is in danger and a war is erupting it means that the entire population is going to be affected. This controversy is stemmed from the opening of a foreign mine. As the islanders begin to work on the mine they become abused and in turn want to gain power and prosperity within the mine. Instead of fighting back, why don’t mines just treat their workers correctly? This would solve wars and the destructions of entire islands and communities. When a foreign based mine is developed, they always export all the profits and leave little to no finances to the laborers. Why not supply the area that is being destroyed by the mining with sufficient funds? Why ship it all away and again create unsettlement and unhappiness? None of my articles have dealt with mining on islands, so this deepened my knowledge regarding all the different possible settings of this controversy. This problem can happen anywhere. Even in my backyard! This piece of literature stemmed from a web site that Mrs. Jewitt discovered and suggested to me. (Thank you Mrs. Jewitt!) I may actually continue researching Bougainville. What I do know is that my final detailed topic is going to be located in a socially and economically unstable country; one that is becoming more fragile with every mine that is opened. Even though I will be specifically focusing on the mine, I will still need background history on the countries status in the world market and its internal standings. With this background information I can show that, a high probability of mines, have a negative impact on society.