Friday, November 20, 2009

Response to Global Effects of Mining

Great Job! The notes form your blog are fantastic and slightly overwhelming. You clearly put a great deal of time and thought into each post. One of the the most noticeable and successful aspects of each post is how well the facts in your notes are separated from the reflection. One thing to keep in mind: the notes are very well written, but be careful not to to weight the reader down with so much information that the core ideas and messages of the post is lost in less important statistics.
As I said above, there is a clear and effective distinction between the facts and your thoughts. I noticed many common themes running through successive posts—the idea of corporation vs. community is very strong, as well as your discussion of various human rights violations and crimes. The best way to evoke emotion from the reader is to leave your response open-ended (which you do for the most part), maybe in a question form so the readers can ask themselves "Huh, why haven't I heard about this huge problem before?" and the like.
Each of the posts vary just enough to keep the reader engages but also interconnect to carry an overall theme. While each topic changes the area or the main problem, everything relates to each other. A good use of this month's background post would be to use one text to thoroughly explain the history of corporate mining and why the situation is as bad as it is now. You have given parts of the description in each post, but a unified base of the topic would be far stronger for the reader and save unnecessary background work later on. Keep an eye on reliable news sources (reuters, NYT, etc.), and double check the websites validity before using it.
The blog itself is complete. well laid-out, and the citation is all correct. The link for The Historic Bolivian Mine UPI story seems to be expired; just double check that. Keep up the great work.