Thursday, October 15, 2009

Vedanta Versus the Villagers: the Fight for the Sacred Mountain- RESPONSE

This article was a great beginning to an eye opening topic. The author interviewed some of the villagers, correlating their opinions with international sentiments. There was a movie that corresponded with the article, which added more of an emphasis on the negative effect this companies mine has bestowed upon the aboriginal people. There was an article in the 2009 January issue of National Geographic that brought to the attention the hard life the communities surrounding mines must experience. It was this article that developed my interest and opinion on the topic. After reading and analyzing this passage, I am adamant about my dislike for the mining companies. Even before I began my I-Search, I already knew what side of this international dilemma I was on. The article didn't change my thinking per say, but it succeeded in feeding my craving mind with more facts. Unless there is an incredibly well written article supporting the corporate side that reveals the benefits of destroying traditional and peaceful communities, then it’ll be hard to waiver my thinking.
I never knew that mining companies had such a low standard for themselves. By cheating these people of their money, land, traditions, resources, and harmony, it seems fair that the companies would endure guilt or some feeling associated with guilt. After reading the article, I now see that they just don’t care. To make money is more important than disrupting an historical tribe. It would be interesting to inquire whether there has been any significant landmark for the tribes or affected people winning against a corporate mine. What must these people go through to be able to live and worship where they have always lived and worshipped? Why is it, that money overpowers human rights? I hope to further research the constant clash between these two assemblies. It’s like a fight to death…literally. My I-Search might develop to become “communities vs. companies: the fight to the end.” Some background information would definitely be needed to research the company’s perspective. I’m currently looking from the point of view of a bystander. I need to see through the eyes of the people, whether they are winning or losing.
At the end of most articles there is a section for comments. After reading an article, I get to the end and ignore the opportunity to react or read reactions from other people. This time though, I decided to see what other individuals around the world felt about not only the article, but this topic. What I encountered was incredible. Not only did people bring up really interesting points, but they also were so passionate about how they felt. I always knew that people were strongly for or against mining and the attributes it has, but I never knew they felt this resolutely! It was also surprising to see the arguments brought up by the people for mining. They aren’t clueless and sophomoric, like I previously thought. Quite the contrary! They were well informed and determined. I may not agree with anything they said, but I still highly respected their opinion. Now, for every article I use, I’ll review the comments because they are beneficial to my research!

Vedanta Versus the Villagers: the Fight for the Sacred Mountain- NOTES

* Vedanta is mining a mountain in the jungle of western Orissa, India that is regarded as sacred by the aboriginal people of the Kondh tribe.
  • Niyamgiri is 600 km from the state capital Bhubaneswar
  • o Only accessible by narrow, unmanaged roads
o No economy

* Vedanta Resources (the british mining compay) wants to create the hillside into a large bauxite mine to supply its refinery at the bottom of the mountain.
o FTSE 100- 100 most highly capitalized UK companies listed on the London Stock Exchange
o The company is run by billionaire Anil Agarwal

* Vedanta wants the refinery to produce at least one million tons of alumina(bauxite) a year
o Kondh people(Dongria, Kutia, Jharania) use the bauxite because it holds water well and helps feed the streams that are used for drinking.
o No bauxite means no water
* Vedanta has run into many local and international protesters and challengers. Human rights organizations and non-profit environmental groups are acting against the mining power house. Vedanta shareholders, including the Church of England are putting pressure on the companies board to reverse its plans. In July, India's supreme court gave permission to start mining.
* Dust and waste has risen the number of tuberculosis cases in the villages. The red mud pond that holds the waste slurry from the refining process is a couple hundred meters away from the Kutia Kondh village of Rengopali
o 12 people have died within the past year; including a nine year old girl and two middle aged woman.
o Dust gets into houses and on food which is later consumed by the people
o Dust and ash from smoke is also effecting the mango, pineapple, orange, and banana trees. The ash cause the flowers to fall off to early, making the fruit fall as well. The quality of all the food is decreasing.
* Vedanta has been trying to win over the aboriginal people and those against their corporation. They stated that they would compensate those that lost land.
o June 25, 2008 was the date of the electrification of the village
o The villagers now have to pay for the electricity even after the company said it was a present from them to the people.
o The company took farming land, and did not compensate many of the people
o Vedanta is cutting down many of the tress around the area, causing the villagers to trek farther and farther away from the village and into the jungle.
* Salesman have showed up trying to sell items that are "modern" but useless to these poverty stricken individuals.
o The small compensation that Vedanta paid some of the people for their land was blown on television sets, satellite dishes, and motorbikes.
o Many have nothing left because the extra financial obligations such as electricity and fuel for their new toys were to expensive.
o Cell phones have been purchased by the villagers that are filling the role of activists so that they can stay in touch. At night, these people used to stand on watch towers to ward of any wild animals from eating their crops, but now they call each other to ward of contractors who want to build roads up the mountain.
* Security guards, patrolling vehicles, motorbikes, barbed wire fences and a huge ditch(similar to a moat) surround the pile of ash that the refinery creates. If there is any sign of approach the security guards come out and stand with their bamboo shields and long weapons.