The process of narrowing down my topic has proven to be substantially difficult. My interests are so broad that it’s hard to choose one area. With the help of a round table discussion that included peers and teachers, I narrowed my thesis down to a sentence that explains my opinion regarding the humanitarian effects that blood minerals have in Africa. This is my first article after the rewriting of my thesis. An idea popped into my head as the search for more articles continued. What if I started looking at each African country and researching the effect blood minerals have had on them. Then during my 15 minute presentation I will travel all around Africa and show the national effect mining has. Now I’m excited!
This piece of literature is actually a report written by a Stanford student. The length has resulted in two blog entries instead of one. This first entry focuses on the history of diamond mining and the DeBeers Company. All the history that was given really gave me a perspective of how long mining has been around and has been a problem. Africa was one of the last countries to have precious gems discovered, but yet it is the country that has suffered the most. I’ve talked about mining a lot, but this essay was the first to include the process of creating the wanted material. Diamonds are not currently my focus, but it was incredible to learn about the origin of my teacher’s new wedding ring. Also, during the roundtable discussion one of my peers had mentioned researching the past of mining. I shot it down because I wanted to focus on the present. What I later realized was that I need to look into the past because there’s a lot of background information that is unbeknownst to me. Much of this information was included in the report. My introduction to the DeBeers Company began with this essay as well. What a greedy company! Of all the scandals that I have researched and written about, the length of this one amazes me. This company has been controlling mining in Sierra Leone and much of Africa for over a decade. They’ve cheated, and mistreated their thousands of workers since the beginning. They are the main force behind illegal diamond mining and smuggling as well as the top controllers of the entire diamond industry. (Very lethal combination if you ask me.) They are nothing but trouble and yet their thunderous voice was only “quieted” once! Now they work as puppeteers, using their smaller branches as their minions. What other countries in Africa have been severely effected by the incorporation of DeBeers into their society? DeBeers says that they are the safe players in the diamond market but what role do they really play? In my notes were just few lines about the connection between DeBeers and Sierra Leone. It’s almost as if DeBeers is a large part of the African government. Next blog will include much more about mining in Sierra Leone and about blood minerals.
·Diamonds are made of pure carbon and are the hardest substance known to man.
oDiamonds are formed over 150 kilometers below the Earth’s surface in the mantle
oOnce they reach the surface, diamonds are located in volcanic pipes known as kimberlite pipes or in loose mineral deposits called alluvial deposits.
§Alluvial deposits are the easiest to excavate because they require little money assistance and do not require highly advanced mining techniques.
·Simplest way to mine these deposits is the use of a shovel and pan.
§Kimberlite pipes require digging a huge pit; breaking the rock into pieces; transporting the rock to a processing plant and repeating this process.
·Only 20% of the world’s diamonds are taken from pipe mines.
·Earliest gem diamonds were found in India and Borneo in riverbeds.
oIn early 18th century deposits were found in Brazil.
oDiamonds were finally discovered in Africa in the mid 19th century.
§Within the next fifteen years African diamond mines produced more diamonds than India had in the last 2,000 years.
·Over 2/3 of the world’s diamonds used to come from the DeBeers company
oThis London based company was one of the first to involve themselves in African diamond mining immediately after the discovery of this mineral.
oCecil Rhodes, the founder of DeBeers, had gained almost complete control of the entire diamond market within 30 years the first diamond in Africa.
§He bought the London Diamond Syndicate, who were the biggest diamond merchants of the time, which allowed him to perfectly match supply with demand
oPredecessors of Rhodes added to his empire including an agreement with the Soviet Union to purchase all their diamonds extracted from one mine.
§Also significantly more sales began to be directed towards the US
·The slogan “Diamonds are forever” was to persuade American middle class buyers to purchase more diamonds.
oThe marketing strategy backfired and despite their success in increasing the demand for diamonds, DeBeers was forced to stockpile a large number of their own diamonds
§The stockpile grew over one million dollars as a result of the increase of illegal diamonds.
oThe U.S. charged DeBeers with violating U.S. antitrust laws, as well as persecuted them for many other things.
oPeople think that DeBeers has disappeared of the diamond market radar, but they still are a main driving force in a very corrupt situation.
·Diamond trading in Sierra Leone began when DeBeers legally took complete control of all mining in the country with a contract for the next 99 years.
oLebanese traders began smuggling the diamonds out of the country because more money was earned instead of working for DeBeers.
§At first the police and government were strong in their arrests, but with so much trafficking of diamonds they gave up (and have yet to step up and end the controversy).
oAll foreign investors were forced to provide their own security for their assets.
oPolice did strengthen their presence in two major diamond cities which led to an illegal diamond pipeline between Sierra Leone and Liberia.
·The government passed the Alluvial Mining Scheme to help diminish illegal mining.
oThe Alluvial Mining Scheme allowed indigenous miners to receive mining and trading licenses
§This of course increased the number of illicit miners by over 75,000.
·Sierra Leone gained independence from Great Britain in the mid 20th century.
oAfter the independence, diamond smuggling grew immensely.
oTerrible leaders led to the governments’ complete involvement in diamond mining.
§Soon the government controlled most of the mines, causing much disruption among the locals who were forced to mine under governmental pressure.
I have yet to have a round table discussion regarding the blog analysis essays, but I did read the reactions and comments that were made on my essay. One of the suggestions included looking deeply into certain perspectives. Instead of having a birds eye view, as I have mentioned in previous responses, I should get an in depth look into the actions and events effecting one side.There was a contradicting suggestion that said I should look farther into the mining company’s point of view. I am unsure as to what side I will choose, but so far I am leaning farther towards focusing on villagers and relief workers. This article revealed the feuds that develop between two mining companies. Major distributors and refiners of the minerals are fighting over the ownership and control of these mineral fertile areas. What they should be debating is how to protect the rights of the civilians they are putting under pressure! Police have taken over towns and blocked transportation. All these local people can do is walk many miles to another village or stay in the overwhelmed towns. There was a statistic in the article that said “35,000 people have entered the area during the past five years, with most entering during the peak in 2008.” That’s about 5 or 6 times the amount of people in the twin villages streaming into an area about 30-40 miles wide. People are so quick in their decisions to join the diamond industry. Local people are marauded by the illusions that diamonds bring success. The chances are about as high as winning the lottery; 1 in every 175.5 million people. It’s the same reason why people are willing to buy the tickets. They only see the amount won by someone and not the risk they are taking by spending so much money (or in the miners case, illegal time) in such a speculative area.
What’s the extent of international aid? Are countries and NGO’s (Non-Governmental Organizations) willing to risk sending their personnel into a war zone? Take a look at the Haiti relief. So much aid has been sent to this ailing country (it is needed!) in less than 3 weeks, but very little has been donated to Chiadzwa or the Democratic Republic of Congo who has been having problems for years. Do organizations feel that Africa is a lost cause? What is the current status regarding aid in the corrupted countries? These are all questions stemmed from money and the willingness of financial assistance organizations to donate. I’m not actually sure what exactly I’m going to research about for my next blog. Maybe I’ll consider staying in DRC and looking father into the companies that are taking over the villages.
Chiadzwa is a town 100 km south west of Mutare in Manicaland.
This is arid province
The discovery of diamonds was expected to improve the town civilians lives but instead is has brought much suffering.
35,000 people have entered the area over the past five years (during the height of illegal diamond mining in 2008)
The government has tried to start formal mining in the area
The would relocate the people to Arda Transau in the Odzi farming area.
The people say the are not farmers so as to demand a stake in the mineral fertile village.
Mbada Diamond Mining and Canadile Miners are two companies interested in the area.
They have injected a combinied intial of US$150 million development capital
A British Company, African Consolidated Resources was granted a right to exploit the minerals.
Disputes of ownerships over the diamond fields are between Mbada and Canadile against ACR.
ACR won.
Companies have given US$10 million for the re-location of the families.
Security personnel search homes, and if anyone is found with large amounts of money they are arrested.
Police and army are beating and killing illegal miners.
There are no public transportation from the village to main roads and hospitals.
Closest hospital is 20km away.
More than 50 buses used to take the route during the height of illegal mining
Chiadzwa is a no-go zone where all entering and leaving is controlled by police.
Heavily guarded trucks carrying diamond ore to the Canadile processing plany off the Odzi River travel the route.
The villagers believe they are being punished by the government for voting in favor of the MDC-T (Movement for the Decocratic Change-Tsvangirai) in the 2008 elections
The MDC-T defeadted Zanu PF's (Zimbabwe African National Union-Patriotic Front).
Single villagers have valued the properties at more than US$100,000.
If they sell they want the money as well as a share in the diamonds.
Chiadzwa diamonds are being smuggled to Mozambique, where they are sold to international purchasers or local mediators.
The villagers feel that all the destruction and annihilation of their village life is due to the gods cursing them for finding diamonds and exploiting them.
Sara - I continue to be fascinated - and horrified - by what your research is turning up. Tin is a metal that one doesn't think of - especially when compared to gold and diamonds - but obviously if the market exists, then the greed and exploitation follow. Your statistics about women and rape - the damage caused by the ramifications of the mining and greed - were indicative of your delving beneath the surface of this topic and finding more cultural impact. I like your thinking on the 3 ways you might proceed from here. Excellent work!!!!!!
There are so many mineral related problems that are conflicting Africa. It’s not just a fight over whose purple crayon is who’s, but a war against who is more willing to kill for what they want. A fight consisting of multiple litigants and one problem: What group can use up all their natural resources first while still destroying entire societies. Congo is just one example of a country declining because of conflict minerals. With so many sources of minerals available to the population, it should have been foreshadowed that a controversy would arise. If the government was truly acting in the favor of the people then, maybe one day, this genocide will end. This website and article gave a much more detailed description into the process of illegally extracting and selling minerals. It also provided facts regarding the status and position of women. Women have very few rights. They are mistreated and abused. Armed groups’ rape and murder girls from captured or destroyed villages. The article stated that about seven thousand girls have reported to be raped since January of 2009. I was so taken aback by this figure, that I decided to calculate approximately how many girls have been affected since 2000. If I did the math right, 63,000 girls have been raped. And it’s all because of greed and selfishness.
One of the aspects that I found helpful was the specific information about the metals being mined. I always thought that gold was the most valued and sought after mineral. What surprised me was that tin was actually the most profitable. Since most electronic companies are using tin in their gadgets, the demand is very high. Every article that I have read, that discusses conflict minerals, has always been about gold or diamonds. Not once has the journalist talked about other metals and their value. Most people here in the United States take tin for granted, but once you start to think about it scrap metal is going for a high price around here. People are stealing parts of cars and other machines to sell as scrap metal and in turn receive a large sum. What is the head price for certain metals in the United States? How desperate are developed countries for these processed or unprocessed minerals? For future articles I would like to research either the effect minerals have on woman, the effect minerals have on already developed countries, or continue learning about the Democratic Republic of Congo. This country is so corrupted that it will be very hard to raise the standards once again and rebuild a great nation.
-The Congolese armed forces, and the Rwandan rebel group the Democratic Forces for the Liberation of Rwanda (FDLR) and other militias are all fighting for the same minerals and mineral sources.
-Armed groups profit from trade in two primary ways:
oControlling the mines, forcing the miners to work in terrible conditions and paying them an average of $1 to $5 per day.
oAccepting bribes from transporters, local and international buyers, and border controls.
-The four main traded minerals are tin, tantalum, tungsten and gold.
oTin is used inside cell phones and other electronic products.
§Armed groups earn approximately $115 million per year.
oTungsten is used to make cell phones or Blackberry’s vibrate.
§Armed groups earn approximately $7 million annually.
oTantalum is used to store electricity in Ipods, digital cameras, and cell phones.
§Armed groups earn approximately $12 million per year.
oGold is mainly used in jewelry but also is a needed for electronics.
§Armed groups earn approximately $50 million per year.
-From eastern Congo the minerals are transported through neighboring countries including Rwanda, Uganda and Burundi.
oStep 2=shipping to east Asia, particularly to multinational smelting companies in Malaysia, Thailand, China, and India.
oStep 3=once processed, minerals are bought by electronic manufacturing companies, turned into usable components and finally added to future electronic devices.
-The highest-selling devices with these minerals include:
oCell phones
oMP3 players
oDigital cameras
oTVs
oComputers
-A recent United Nations report showed evidence that a Thailand-based tin smelting company, the fifth largest in the world, has been purchasing minerals linked to the FDLR, the armed groups responsible for the 1994 Rwanda genocide.
-American and German-based tantalum processing companies, and Belgian metals-trading companies have also been discovered to be purchasing minerals from other armed groups in eastern Congo, the CNDP(National Congress for the Defense of the People) and the FARDC( Armed Forces of the Democratic Republic of Congo).
-$184 is the average annual income for a Congolese civilian, which equals $0.50 per day.
-About 1,300 Congolese continue to die each day as a consequence of war.
-The estimated profits made each year by armed groups from the trade in eastern Congo’s minerals are about $180 million.
-Approximately 6,000 houses have been burned down in North and South Kivu
-There are 2 hospitals in all of eastern Congo that are able to perform surgeries to repair fistula.
-The number of rape cases reported by woman and girls since January 2009 is around 7,000.
-46 years is the average life expectancy for a woman living in the Democratic Republic of Congo.
-900,000 Congolese have been forced to flee from their homes in eastern Congo due to violence since January 2009.
Now that I have decided to focus on blood minerals, I feel that my articles are becoming more interesting. Before I had narrowed down my options, every article was practically the same. They were all well written and included a lot of important information, but it came to a point where the same thing got to be rather mundane. This article wasn’t written in the typical reporters voice. Each phrase contained passion and was opinionated. Some may say that this is a negative aspect because it could be qualified as biased, but I feel that it’s important to read this style because it shows you the public’s feelings. I will try to balance this author’s opinion with the opposite, or one from the point of view of the Zimbabwe government. I have mentioned in previous blogs that I will try to research government actions and I have yet to follow through. This time will be the charm! This article focused a lot on local versus the government. This is a huge problem because the government gives the rebels (locals) weapons, and in turn the rebels give the government diamonds. It may seem like they are fighting against each other but with such corruption they are actually in the war together. The words of this article strengthened my knowledge about this never-ending cycle.
There were no changes in my thinking, but my knowledge was deepened. I learned that there are some groups within the conflicted countries that are openly critical of their governments. I assumed that all national NGO’s would be silenced or severely punished for chastising the military. In truth I didn’t even recognize the fact that there were national NGO’s. All the articles have talked about international groups such as United Nations and its affiliates. Some questions that are worth pondering include; How can these diamonds benefit the local economy as opposed to the international one? Will the halting of purchases from international companies help, or hurt? Would international aid, or military assistance be useful, or would that just provide a cover for corruption? If the United States sent over military aid, the rebels and government would have one more person to fight against. Instead of calming the waters it would just create massive swells. Locals wouldn’t want help from soldiers. The only assistance the soldiers could provide would be to capture rebels’. That as well wouldn’t solve any problems because the government is in sync with the rebels. The only way to completely stop the mass murders and eradicate any violence is to either stop mining completely, or capture all the rebels and replace the entire government. Either way is impossible. It would also take years to rebuild and stabilize a new government, and there will always be someone that disagrees with its actions.
I am not sure whether I will continue with blood diamonds because there are also problems with conflict gold. Maybe I’ll try to focus on one country such as the Democratic Republic of Congo, Sierra Leone, or Zimbabwe but deal with both conflict gold and diamonds. There’s a lot of background history need to explain blood minerals. So much has been tried to stop the problem, but so little has worked. I would like to research previous actions from governments and NGO’s, as well as reactions from the locals and rebels.
For this world to change, society must become motivated. When a legal document is created by an organization whose members include 98% of the world’s countries, it must be important. The United Nations doesn’t consist of 192 lazy teenagers that would rather procrastinate than face the work in front of them. When the Kimberly Process was created, it was a huge step in the right direction. The mining of blood diamonds had been plaguing the world for more than a decade, and this sanction was created to stop this action. The world rejoiced and slowly the problem was forgotten. It has now been dealt to our attention that this treaty, created by the motivated UN, is being disregarded and undermined (excuse the pun). Rebels are still forcing people into labor, raping woman, and having children work. It’s destroying the lives of many especially the woman who end up impregnated with a child they can’t support, and for the children who will never forget what they had to endure. What low standards these rebels must have. If I knew that I was killing and raping innocent people for my own personal benefit, I would be overpowered by guilt. How can these officials and rebels ignore that guilt? Is it humanely possible the walk by a dead person without a single hint of remorse? They are breaking an agreement, one that is trying to protect the lives of many. It’s absolutely disgusting. The Kimberly Process was created to help stop these wars. Instead it has created a mask for the countries to hide under. “A lot of governments have been happy to use the Kimberley Process as a fig leaf of respectability, so they can say, ‘OK, look we're doing something.’” NGOs are trying to incorporate human rights into the treaty, but I’m sure that many of the countries will not agree to treating their citizens with respect. My last article spotlighted Congo and its gold war. I was greatly moved by the numbers of people affected by this greed. It influenced me to focus my blog solely on the mining in Africa. This country is drowning in the blood of its citizens, and much of the sorrow is caused by mining. Corrupt governments and rebel militias destroy communities and societies. My next goal will be to choose a mineral in Africa that has and will continue being a source of conflict. This article was really helpful in that it showed the wide range of mineral wars that are occurring all over Africa. This isn’t just a problem that is located in one area of this grand continent. It would prove fruitful to research other sanctions that were adopted regarding mining and society. It would also be interesting to maybe focus on what the UN has done. They are the world’s most respected governing body, and include the voices of many. Have governments been open to introducing new rules? Have developed countries such as the USA, and China aided to stopping the wars? Are companies tracking their jewels (mentioned as well in my previous article)?
Conflict diamonds/blood diamonds are rough stones mined at gunpoint by slaves and prisoners for the enrichment of those holding the weapons.
In 2003 the Kimberley Process was adopted.
It’s a UN-sanctioned agreement between 75 countries that import and export diamonds, diamond industry leaders and nongovernmental organizations.
The mission is to certify that diamonds on sale did not arrive there at the expense of murdered and mutilated Africans.
Countries that violate the agreement are expelled or suspended, meaning they can no longer export their diamonds to any of the agreement’s member countries.
Sierra Leone, Angola, and the Democratic Republic of Congo can’t track as much as 50% of the diamonds they export.
Cote d’Ivoire, the only country considered to be the source of “official” blood diamonds has expanded its production since the UN sanction in 2004 concluding that they are finding customers some where else.
The Kimberley Process is has produced little change and has even encouraged more illegal trade.
Zimbabwe has resulted in a bad representation of the Kimberley Process.
Since 2006, when the country discovered its diamonds, the country’s police and military have destroyed neighborhoods and the publics trust towards their country.
Garrisons of soldiers order civilians to dig diamonds at gunpoint.
Miners are beat.
Woman are raped.
Children are forced into labor.
To secure the diamond fields and clear them of unlicensed independent diggers the military conducted a “scorched earth operation”.
Hundreds of people died.
The diamonds are smuggled into Mozambique and then exported out under the cover of the Kimberly Process.
Zimbabwe has not been suspended but given a grace period to clean up its act..
The Kimberley Process is being called upon by NGOs to include human rights provisions.
Boycotts of Zimbabwean diamonds are being held.
It was boycotts that scared the diamond industry and inspired the Kimberley Process’s creation.
Gold and other mined minerals are funding the deadliest war since World War II.
5 million people have died in the Democratic Republic of Congo.
No ban has been initiated for blood gold as it has for blood diamonds.
The death rate is extraordinarily high in these mines.
Mudslides and regular rock falls are the top death causes.
These miners, mostly illegal, are lucky to make one dollar or two a day..
Nobody has healthcare, or social insurance.
Children are sent to work as early as possible, and most never earn another job for "the rest of their lives."
The mining methods are at least 2,000 years old.
The miners lay blankets into the riverbed, wait for the fibers to collect sediment, then wring out the blankets, mix mercury with the sediment, burn the mercury away and search for any flakes of gold.
The mercury binds the gold together.
The burning of mercury releases incredibly toxic fumes, which cause severe neurological damage during the process of aging.
In 1996, Uganda and Rwanda invaded Congo. Seven more countries joined in and started stealing Congo’s resources. The invasion was terminated, but rebel militias and government forces have continued to fight over power, and control of the minerals.
In some cases, government troops have been discovered selling weapons to rebels.
Rebels attack the civilian population constantly.
"These attacks scare the people and terrorize them into submission. The civilians are then forced to work in the mines for the militia groups."
Civilian camps have been created for displaced villagers.
There are over 100 camps in the country, and they have served 1 million individuals.
These camp provide safety and food.
Camps are attacked routinely.
200,000 women have been raped in eastern Congo.
Rape has become a weapon used by the rebels. Woman must go out to scavenge for wood and food, That is when they are abducted and raped by the soldiers.
Much of the mined gold is smuggled into Uganda’s capital, Kampala.
Uganda has almost no gold production (in 2007 it produced around $500) but somehow exported over $75 million in gold.
Around 1% of the world market is fed by Congo gold.
I have begun to realize that my topic is too broad. Its generalization covers so many areas and has yet to become focused. I’m not learning anything new. Each article is about the same process; A town getting socially destroyed by a mine. Once I narrow down my research I’ll be able to focus on one town, country, or continent and its history. After reading this article I plan researching mining in Africa. This may develop into specifically gold mining, but diamond controversies have also caught my eye. I was hooked on this article, after reading the line “Gold and other minerals are funding the deadliest war since World War II. More than five million people have died in the Democratic Republic of Congo”. This completely changed my thinking. Minerals are one of the four elements: earth, wind, water, and fire. I have always known that the people of this earth are greedy. But to kill 5 million people over a piece of rock is absurd. That’s about one half or one third of the total people killed in Hitler’s holocaust. To murder because of greed and ignorance is a standard that I hope nobody would ever reach. It’s comparable to a small group of children killing the entire population of Maryland because they want all the purple crayons in all the crayon boxes.
This article brought up an interesting point. Large scale venders of gold are ignorant of the history behind their merchandise. They are unable to trace the mineral all the way back to where it was excavated. How is this helping to stimulate the war in Congo or any other mineral based war? Are these companies seeing only what they want to see? Why? There must be some law that forces vendors to trace their imports so as to be able to answer a customer when he/she asks, “Where did this come from?”. Whenever someone portrays what is happening in the Congo, dictatorship, wars and whatever bad, there is always one thing missing: The masterminds. Western countries through their multinationals have always been the masterminds of whatever war, crime and plundering that have been going on in the Congo. They don't show them, they only show the puppets they are using. Most are from foreign countries such as Uganda or Rwanda. The west can solve ninety five percent of this problem if we take initiative and stop purchasing blood gold. I have also become disgusted by the treatment of woman in these violence stricken areas.These women have no rights. Once their families and husbands die, their gender creates an inability to work or financially support themselves. If they haven’t already been raped, then a large percentage will. I am incredibly interested in Africa, and hope to continue with this subject.
Mining has caused global disasters affecting the environment and humanity. By exposing the negative features of excavating minerals, I hope to demonstrate the need and possibility for change in society.